The New York Jets 2027 mock draft storyline out of ESPN's midseason projections isn't really about where New York picks. It's about what they'd give up to pick somewhere else entirely.
Jordan Reid's latest first-round projection, built off the order the season would produce if it ended today, has the Jets packaging two of their three original first-round selections, the No. 4 and No. 13 picks, along with a 2028 third-rounder, and sending all of it to the Chargers just to climb two spots to No. 2. That's a steep toll for two slots. It tells you everything about how badly Reid thinks a rebuilding front office wants its quarterback of the future, and who that quarterback is.
who has the no 1 pick in the 2027 nfl draft
Reid's board starts in Nashville. The Titans, sitting at 1-8 through the midpoint of the season, hold the top selection, and Reid doesn't give it to a quarterback or a pass rusher. He gives it to Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith.
That's the quiet earthquake buried in this exercise. No receiver has gone first overall since the Jets took Keyshawn Johnson in 1996, and Johnson remains only the third wideout ever picked at the top of a draft, following Irving Fryar in 1984. Smith is averaging 131.7 receiving yards per game, second in the FBS, while playing through quarterback instability at Ohio State. Scouts keep reaching for names like Calvin Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald and Julio Jones to describe him, and at 6-foot-4 and 225 pounds with the speed to still win vertically, it's not hard to see why. Pairing him with 2025's No. 1 overall pick, Cam Ward, would hand Tennessee a two-driver offense almost overnight.
Checked the almanac on this one, because it mattered: Johnson's rookie Jets team went 1-15 the year he arrived, a reminder that a generational prospect doesn't fix a roster by himself. Johnson still made three Pro Bowls and finished with over 10,500 career receiving yards. The player can be right even when the team around him isn't ready yet.
why are the jets trading up for a quarterback
New York's half of this is the part with the most moving pieces. Reid has the Jets sending out the No. 4 and No. 13 picks, the latter of which they originally got from Dallas in the Quinnen Williams trade, plus a future third-rounder, to jump from No. 4 to No. 2 and take Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker.
That's not a cheap move, and it's not supposed to be. The Jets have spent three straight first rounds building a floor around the passing game: tackles Olu Fashanu and Armand Membou on back-to-back boards, wide receiver Omar Cooper Jr., tight end Kenyon Sadiq, and the established presence of Garrett Wilson already on the roster. Reid's read is that the only piece missing is the guy throwing it, and that New York views Mestemaker as worth cashing in draft capital rather than risking someone else jumps the line first.
The scouting community mostly agrees on the name, if not the price. In a midseason poll of 25 NFL scouts and executives, Mestemaker was the runaway pick to be the first quarterback off the board in 2027, drawing 17 of 25 votes, the largest margin in that poll's three-year history. That's a notable level of agreement this early. Through the season he's completed 67.0% of his passes for 1,940 yards, 16 touchdowns and six interceptions, adding 142 yards and two scores on the ground, and he's projected to finish with 27 career starts by season's end. The number that should slow anyone down: only 20 of those starts have come against Power 4 competition, and his path started as a walk-on at North Texas before he landed at Oklahoma State. The ceiling is real. So is the sample-size caveat that comes with it.
is jeremiah smith really worth the no 1 overall pick
It's worth sitting with how rare this projection actually is. Thirty years between receivers at No. 1 overall is a long gap in a league that drafts a quarterback or a pass rusher at the top almost by reflex. Smith's production is forcing the conversation anyway, and Reid isn't hedging: he calls him the best player in the entire class, full stop, not just the best non-quarterback.
If Tennessee actually sits at the top of the draft come spring, the Smith pick would also say something about where Ward's development stands. A team doesn't spend the first overall pick on a receiver unless it believes the quarterback room is settled. Pairing Smith with 2026 first-rounder Carnell Tate, his old Ohio State running mate, would give Ward one of the more talented receiving rooms in the league before his third season even starts.
which other prospects are rising in the 2027 class
The quarterback and the receiver get the headlines, but Reid's board has real separation at a few other spots worth tracking.
| Prospect | Position, School | Reid's Overall Rank | Signature Number |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chris Cole | LB, Georgia | 5 | 11 tackles for loss, 3 sacks, 2 defensive TDs through 8 games |
| Ashton Hampton | CB, Clemson | 8 | 26.8% completion rate allowed into his coverage, 2nd among FBS corners |
| Jamari Johnson | TE, Oregon | 20 | 50.6 receiving yards per game, 10th among FBS tight ends |
Cole is the one Reid sounds most certain about, describing a gap between him and the next linebacker on the board as "Grand Canyon-sized." He's got the fumble-return highlight reel to match the tackling numbers, including a 66-yard scoop-and-score. Hampton profiles as a press-man corner teams covet in an era obsessed with stopping big, physical receivers, which is a little funny given Smith is the headliner of his own class. Johnson, meanwhile, lands with Kansas City in Reid's projection as the heir apparent to Travis Kelce, a graceful way of saying the Chiefs still don't have a real answer at tight end beyond this season.
There's a defensive thread running through parts of this board too. The wire has carried word this week that Miami's defensive line has been gutted by injury, with Jordan Phillips lost for the year to a torn biceps, the third defensive tackle Miami has lost this season. Reid's mock has the Dolphins using an early pick on a projected top pass rusher, which tracks given that context, even if the full detail on that prospect didn't come through cleanly. And Dallas, whose defense currently ranks last in the league in total yards allowed per game, has the kind of need that tends to show up on these boards in bold print by midseason.
how accurate are early mock drafts anyway
Worth remembering what this exercise actually is: a snapshot, not a forecast. Reid's own early mock from the prior draft cycle had 32 names on it; 12 eventually went in the first round as projected, and four others didn't declare at all, returning to school instead. That's a real hit rate, but it's not a high one, and it's the honest reason nobody should treat a November mock as settled business. Standings move. Underclassmen change their minds. Trades that make sense in a hypothetical rarely survive contact with an actual war room.
What doesn't change between now and April is the stuff that got us here: the Titans' record, the Jets' three straight drafts spent building around a passer who isn't on the roster yet, and a receiver at Ohio State playing well enough to make NFL teams rethink thirty years of draft-day instinct. The order will shuffle. The draft itself doesn't happen until April in Washington, D.C. Whether New York actually finds a trade partner willing to move off the No. 2 pick, and whether Tennessee's record holds up enough to keep the top selection, are the two threads worth pulling on as the second half of the season plays out.