No. 14 Oregon beat Michigan State 45-7 on Friday night in East Lansing, and on paper that's the whole story: four straight wins, a climb to No. 13 in the CFP rankings, a program still breathing in the race for the 12-team field. But the Ducks won this one the way they've won the last month, which is to say with the next man up, because the man before him is either on crutches or hasn't played since September.
Brandon Smith, Oregon's third-string running back three weeks ago, ran for a career-high 121 yards and two touchdowns. He broke a scoreless tie late in the first quarter on a 5-yard score and added another in the third. That's the headline. The subplot, and it's becoming the whole plot, is that Smith got those carries because Oregon keeps losing running backs, and on Friday night it lost one more.
Why did Dierre Hill leave the Michigan State game?
Dierre Hill Jr., who'd taken over as Oregon's lead back with Jordon Davison out, limped off in the first quarter and was on crutches with a walking boot by halftime. Before he exited he'd carried twice for 17 yards. He came into the night as Oregon's leading rusher, 589 yards and five touchdowns on the season, with 25 catches for 289 more yards out of the backfield. Coach Dan Lanning said after the game he didn't anticipate a long-term injury, which is the kind of sentence a program hopes holds up better than the last three times it's been said this fall.
How bad is Oregon's running back injury situation?
Pretty bad, and it's been building for weeks. Davison missed his third straight game Friday with a leg injury suffered against Northwestern on Oct. 31, a situation that was first described as week-to-week and has now stretched into a month. Quarterback Dante Moore, a preseason Heisman name who came back to Eugene for his senior year instead of entering the draft, hasn't played since a concussion against USC on Sept. 26, and Lanning has said he doesn't expect Moore back this season at all. Add Hill to that pile and Oregon has now lost its top two backs and its starting quarterback to injury inside of two months, and it's still winning.
| Player | Role | Status | Season rushing yards | Season TDs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brandon Smith | 3rd-string RB | Played, starred | 121 (vs. MSU) | 2 (vs. MSU) |
| Dierre Hill Jr. | RB1 (before injury) | Out, boot/crutches | 589 | 5 |
| Jordon Davison | Former starter | Out 3 straight games | 439 | 7 |
| Dante Moore | Starting QB | Out since Sept. 26 | , | , |
That's the math of an 8-3 team that's won four in a row almost entirely on the backs of the next guy in line. Dylan Raiola, pressed into the starting job by Moore's concussion, threw for 234 yards and a touchdown against Michigan State, a one-handed grab in the end zone by Dakorien Moore, and he's gone five straight games without an interception. Kicker Gage Hurych even scored a touchdown on a fake field goal, sprinting 15 yards after taking a direct snap and pitch, which tells you something about a roster willing to get creative when its depth chart keeps getting rearranged.
Can a three-loss Oregon team make the College Football Playoff?
This is the part that makes Oregon's season genuinely unusual, not just gritty. Through the first two years of the 12-team playoff, only two three-loss teams ever got in: Clemson in 2024 as the ACC champion, and Alabama in 2025 as an at-large team that had actually lost its conference title game, 28-7 to Georgia, and still made the field. Those are the only two examples. Oregon, sitting at three losses with no path to even play in a Big Ten title game this year, would be charting new ground entirely, the first three-loss team to make the field without a conference championship appearance of any kind. A few weeks ago, after a loss to Illinois dropped the Ducks to 4-3, that would have sounded like a reach. Four straight wins later, climbing to No. 13, it's a live question for the committee instead of a punchline.
check the almanac on this one: Alabama's 2025 berth was the proof of concept that a three-loss team could get in at all, and it took a loss in the conference championship game to get there. Oregon is trying to pull off a version of that trick without even getting to the stage.
What's next for Michigan State and Pat Fitzgerald?
For Michigan State, there isn't much left to salvage. The Spartans fell to 3-8 and 1-7 in the Big Ten, outscored 28-7 after halftime following a second quarter full of self-inflicted wounds: a missed 47-yard field goal, a fumbled punt return that set up an Oregon score, a freshman quarterback stumbling untouched on a fourth-down run. Kayd Coffman, starting for the second time in place of the injured Alessio Milivojevic, finished 10 of 19 for 106 yards with an interception. Jaziun Patterson's 1-yard touchdown late in the third quarter was Michigan State's only answer on the board all night.
Pat Fitzgerald is about a week from closing the book on his first season in East Lansing, and it's been a hard one: five straight losing seasons now for a program that keeps hiring a new voice to fix the same problem. The Spartans close the year at Rutgers on Nov. 28, a chance to avoid a fourth straight loss before the full offseason evaluation begins.
What I'm watching
Oregon hosts Washington on Nov. 28 to close the regular season, and the health report between now and then matters more than almost anything else in the playoff conversation. If Hill's injury is as minor as Lanning suggested, Oregon gets its deepest healthy backfield of the stretch run back just in time. If it isn't, Brandon Smith keeps carrying a workload nobody drew up for him in August, and Oregon's playoff case gets built on a rookie's shoulders in a rivalry game that decides whether all of this was enough.